Kids and Chores
An uncomfortable look at children, chores, and the popular assumption that they owe us labour
You didn't birth (or adopt, or foster) a possession or a robot – or a slave
Parents argue 'we all need to work together as a family' and 'I work hard...' 'they need to learn how' and 'I need a break.' All of these may be true, but they're unrelated to any specific child obeying and specific domestic order in any specific situation... Starting with:
Linda says: you chose this.
Electing to become (or stay) a parent brings a long list of extra work, from additional meals to more laundry, more stuff at home, and demands on an adult's space, time, attention, and funds. These additional demands are a result of an adult's choice, not debts incurred by children.
We aren't loaning (with or without interest) them our home, our food, our money, our attention, or our clean and tidy space. All that long list is the adult's duty of care. Children do not owe adults anything. Not gratitude, not payback, and absolutely not free labour.
When did having children become a justification for demanding unpaid labour from them?
Parenting is not a sacrifice. It's a choice, and a responsibility.
There are three familiar justifications for expecting children to do household work. Let's examine what each one actually establishes...
The Debate, part 1
Be it resolved that the truth of kids doing chores is: ‘we all need to work as a family.’
Opposed: How do you know that’s true?
Affirmative: It’s self-evident: it’s our home and we need to work together for it to be peaceful and healthy
Opposed: A bit of a circle of logic, there, but how ‘healthy’ is it to put kids in a position of opposition to the people they need to live? How peaceful is it to order people around? How peaceful do you find resistance and rebellion?
And perhaps most importantly: does membership in a family create an obligation to perform assigned work?
The Debate, part 2
Be it resolved that the truth of kids doing chores is ‘mom/dad needs a break.’
Opposed: How do you know that’s true?
Affirmative: I/we work hard.
Opposed: Good. Hard work is good for people, especially their mental health. What’s mom/dad ‘needing a break’ got to do with kids?
Affirmative: They can help, so they should
Opposed: Sorry, that’s a syllogism: you can, too, so you should do it.
Affirmative: There aren’t enough hours in the day, they have to pitch in
Opposed: There are 24 hours in every day which you can spend any way you choose. Your time should be spent on your priorities: if it’s important to you, do it. If it is less important to you… why should anyone else do it?
Affirmative: My skills and talents are far superior to the work, someone whose time is less valuable should do menial work
Opposed: Therefore, let’s not be coy: a child’s time is less valuable to you than yours is, so they can do the less valuable tasks to free you up to do the more meaningful and valuable and rewarding tasks with your much more worthwhile life, yes?
Could you demonstrate how your time is more valuable to your children than their time is to them? Or perhaps argue simply that your life is more valuable than theirs, and with it you are entitled to leisure time that they are not?
Affirmative: Well, I pay them for chores, so I clearly value them
Opposed: Do you pay them what their time is worth to them or what your time is worth to you? Or a couple of bucks? Or a quarter?
The argument that an adult is tired or overtaxed doesn't make the child the resource for an adult to use.
Or, as streetproofing training tries to impress on vulnerable children: adults ask adults for help with adult needs; adults meet kids' needs.
The Debate, part 3
Be it resolved that the truth of kids doing chores is ‘they need to learn how.’
Opposed: How do you know that’s true?
Affirmative: Because all adults need to know how.
Opposed: Okay, without referring to all the adults who hire out that work to pros, let’s pretend that’s true: how long would it take an adult to learn to sweep a floor or wash a toilet? Ten minutes? Fifteen if they had to add a lecture on cleaning supplies and tools?
How long do you think the training is for a professional maid to be completely qualified? A week? Three days? Half a day? How is this an argument for eight-year-old kids doing the same task even once a month?
Aren't we confusing learning a skill (fairly simple and easy) with owing someone the use of that skill?
The Deeper Issue
We've confused obligation with participation
Kids can take pride in their activities, while developing skills, preferences and interests, and enjoy cooperating. They will learn to see what needs to be done, and use their own initiative.
That is the goal, right? Placid participation and cooperation in keeping the house comfortable, yes?
Obligation doesn't belong in there, at all. In fact, I'll argue for the rest of time, that obligation demolishes that.
The problem isn't that children do or don't participate in household chores. The problem is adults seeing that participation as something they're entitled to control and benefit from.
Participation is not equivalent to taking on responsibility for family life.
The Underlying Problems – Attitude, Resistance, Obedience to Others
So often, parents want kids to go along with things based on the way they had to, long ago: just smile and pretend you're enjoying it, stop fussing, get on with it.
As a culture we're trending toward more respectful care of our children, with more understanding about how they are real people with valid feelings and opinions...But we still ask these kinds of questions, with problems embedded in them:
Question 1. How can I improve my kids’ attitudes toward helping out at home?
Answer 1. Check your attitude. The odds are excellent that your kids are mirroring yours, venting yours, or just agreeing with you yours.
Question 1.a. My attitude is excellent: I know it needs to be done, I know it’s ‘work now, play later.’ I know it’s important to get things done.
Answer 1.a. I’m not hearing ‘I enjoy and value this work while I’m doing it –I plan it and look forward to it.’
Question 1.b. What kind of nutcase feels that way about cleaning toilets?
Answer 1.b. You’d be amazed –but it’s the attitude you want someone to tell you how to install in your kids. If you can’t find it within reality, how on earth can they?
It really is a strange idea, that something we find disgusting or unreasonable should be seen any differently by someone we want to delegate it to.
Question 2. I really need kids to pitch in (write in reason of choice: single parent, busy schedule, ailing parents, demanding job, kids waste time, they have to, it’s their turn…) how do I get them to help out?
Answer 2. Actually, answer this first: how much of what you do in a day is optional? TV, computer time, re-organizing organized things, cleaning clean things, pampering, socializing…
Response 2. I deserve a break.
Answer to Response 2. From what?
Justification for 2. From all the drudgery and hard, menial work I do for them –laundry, cleaning, tidying, picking up after them, shopping, cooking…
Answer to Justification for 2. First, you're not doing this 'for them' you're doing this as part of your duty of care because you chose to have them. But also, this: it sounds like you feel that the work you do is beneath you, and somehow that means you’re entitled to free labour from ‘not really people’ (or maybe more benignly, 'not you') because that’s what kids are for: slavery?
Response 2.a. No, no, no! Not at all!! They need to learn to do it and I need a break.
Answer to 2.a. Popular answers, but still failing to address the topic: no child must help adults with adult work. See, 'streetproofing' above.
Adults are responsible for the state of their home, and the standards of cleanliness and tidiness they wish to demonstrate for their children. Not the other way around.
Question 3. How can I make my child listen?
Answer 3. You mean 'obey.'
Response 3. No, no, no, not at all.
Answer to response 3. Oh, yes, you do. You just shy from the word 'obey.' You still mean 'how can I make my kid do what I want my kid to do not matter what they're doing or what they want to do?'
Question 3.a. Well, okay... maybe. But how?
Answer 3.a. Go back to the beginning and order a child with the Voice Command Software pre-installed. Sorry, it is not available aftermarket. There is no app for that.
That is: expecting children to be robots or slaves or to act as if they're possessions instead of whole real people is guaranteed to provide endless supplies of frustration, and if parents decide to keep pushing, also astonishing levels of resistance and rebellion.
Question 4. Why do my kids do what the teacher (scout leader, neighbours, etc.) tell them to do and it never works for me?
Answer 4. Because your kid trusts you. You can destroy that, if obedience is more important...
Question 4.a. No, no, I don't want obedience, I just want them to _________ [fill in blank] when I ask them to.
Answer 4.a. Yes: you do want them to obey orders.
Okay, Okay, I Win.
But some kids do chores, happily – want to know how?
Surrender works so well in so many areas of parenting (and life) –it is when we stop struggling with reality that we find ease and peace.
One note for clarification: surrender is not sacrifice. Sacrifice is for martyrs, not people who seek happiness, effectiveness, joy, peace, connection or love. Martyrs may get admiration ...maybe. What they will get is resentment, avoidance, criticism (which is ironic, because they are trying to avoid it) and derision.
Regarding chores, there are several aspects of surrender that are very helpful to create a peaceful and healthy home – you know, the kind children might ever happily pitch in to do the work in:
Surrender to the reality of time constraints
You can do it all, just not all at once. Priorities need to be evaluated so you’re not wasting your life –or trying to waste anyone else’s—on things you don’t genuinely value.
Surrender to the necessity of the task
Before enlightenment: chop wood, carry water
After enlightenment: chop wood, carry water
There will be no time in your life when feeding and cleaning does not need to be done, however much modern conveniences ease the work. Accept that it must be done, without end.
Surrender to the real equality
All people need feeding and cleaning: of all the base, common and menial drudgery, none can be less exalted than ‘voiding bladder and bowel.’ We all get to do that with part of our days, no matter who we think we are – 5 cent/hour garbage pickers in Brazil and $30,000/minute superstar athletes, and everyone in between. You can value this real aspect of life or revile it, but no one is worth so much, and no one is worth so much less than you, to have to do it for you.
It is deeply disrespectful of humans to hold the opinion that the work is beneath you but not them. (I learned this from a boss: never ask anyone to do anything you're not willing to do happily.)
Surrender to the power of mindless repetition –and hard work
All the effort spent (and technology invented) just to avoid the peace and ease of simple, repetitive work is astonishing.
The dedication modern folk give to avoiding some of the easiest and most instantly-gratifying work available is amazing. A cleaned plate is clean: visibly, obviously and it is ‘finished.’
So much work is never done, has no clear product or is so complex and involves so many people that our part in it is (or feels) both invisible and impersonal. A clean plate is clean. A planted garden is planted. A cooked meal is ready to eat.
Surrender to the fleeting nature of life
Yes, the meal will be eaten and the plate will once again need cleaning, but such is the nature of life. What is it that, once done, need never be redone or will never be undone? A singer walks off the stage and the song has ended. It can be re-sung, of course, but that performance is over. Even a recording of the thing is not the thing –it was live with a live audience and now it is a recording of both. Why is that less distressing than the laundry that needs re-washing?
Find the joys in doing, not in only having done. Life is a process, not a product.
Surrender to the chaos
Unless you seek to live alone forever, chaos will always be your roommate. Other people are ‘other’ –they see things differently, they react because they have a different perspective. The desire to live in peaceful harmony forever precludes living with other humans at any age.
Even if you did not understand the deal you were signing up for, the decision to have children comes with the built-in guarantee of a life filled with chaos. Will you fight it like it’s an unwanted intruder, or accept it as the inevitability it is, like static or dust?
Surrender, finally, to your own personal preferences
Do what you will, as you will.
It is only within this freedom and self-respect that you can find worth in your work –and free others to see the worth in the work you do, and perhaps even find value in doing it themselves.
The secret of children happily cooperating in their own homes is an atmosphere of joy, worthiness and respect for the value of the work, and the value of the product of the work.
A parent who finds himself sneering at the idea of washing a floor cannot be surprised by a child’s distaste for the task. Equally, a man happily engaged in nurturing his family through meal preparations may well find cooperative bodies eager to share the room and help.
Joy, enthusiasm and a sense of an important job well done are all attractive, and contagious. When you feel resistance from your kids, check to see how you really feel about the work... and also if you believe the work involved is necessary to do at all (some isn't.)
And, just to be really clear:
Adults don't have to enjoy housework or parenting. You don't have to enjoy every moment or every domestic task. You don't have to pretend the work is wonderful.
We do have to stop treating our feelings about that work as an injustice for which children are responsible.
You can hate doing laundry. You can resent the endless dishes. You can decide that your standards need adjusting, hire help, form a co-op with other adults who hate housework, simplify your life, ask a friend who actually loves doing it, or leave the floor less than pristine.
Those are adult decisions.
You don't get to make your child responsible for alleviating your to do list because 'they're family' or 'they need to learn' or 'I need a break.'
The funny thing is, once all the pushing and resistance are gone from inside the parents, not only is it far easier to encourage cooperation from kids, free of all the being pushed and intensity by parents, kids will surprise themselves and their parents by pitching in cheerfully, voluntarily when they want to.